Map it with MapQuest

From the Oakland area via Route 208 or Route 287:

Exit onto Skyline Drive heading west. Proceed to the end of Skyline Drive at Greenwood Lake Tpke.

Make a right turn onto Greenwood Lake Tpke; make the next right onto Skylands Road. At Cupsaw Plaza, make a left turn toward the water through the plaza, then make an immediate left turn at the water onto Carletondale Road. Stay on Carletondale Road for a little over one mile. The church will be on your left, just past the Board of Education building.

From the Wanaque area via Ringwood Avenue:

Go north on Ringwood Avenue past Skyline drive; make the next right onto Skylands Road. At Cupsaw Plaza, make a left turn toward the water through the plaza, then make an immediate left turn at the water onto Carletondale Road. Stay on Carletondale Road for a little over one mile. The church will be on your left, just past the Board of Education building.

From the West Milford area via Greenwood Lake Turnpike:

Proceed around the reservoir toward Skyline Drive. Before Skyline Drive, make a left turn onto Sloatsburg Road.

Make a right turn onto Carletondale Road; the church will be a short distance on your right.